top of page
Search

Cabbage Key - Step Back In Time

  • Writer: Jenn Flaa
    Jenn Flaa
  • 4 days ago
  • 2 min read

Get your Cheeseburger in Paradise


If you’re looking for a true “Old Florida” experience, Cabbage Key is one of those places that feels like it hasn’t changed in decades—in the best possible way.


Only accessible by boat, this small island just off Pine Island feels completely removed from the everyday world. No cars, no crowds, no rush. Just sandy paths, open air, and that laid-back, barefoot Florida vibe.


What Makes It Special

Cabbage Key is often tied to the legend of Jimmy Buffett’s “Cheeseburger in Paradise.” While that story isn’t fully confirmed, you can grab a cheeseburger and a cold drink at the island restaurant—so it’s easy to see where the inspiration might have come from.


One of the most famous spots is the “dollar bill bar,” where visitors have been leaving signed bills for years. It’s quirky, fun, and very much part of the charm.


What to Expect

This is not a resort. And that’s exactly the point.

Think:

  • Walking trails instead of golf carts

  • Fishing off the dock

  • Reading a book in the breeze

  • Live music and stories at the bar

It’s more about slowing down than filling up your schedule.


Day Trip vs. Overnight

Most people visit for lunch by boat, and it can get lively around midday when the docks fill up.

But if you stay overnight, you’ll experience the best parts—quiet mornings and peaceful evenings when the day crowd leaves.



Getting There

  • By private boat (most common)

  • By water taxi or charter

  • Often combined with a shelling stop at Cayo Costa


Tips from the Island

  • Go early—dock space is first come, first served

  • Bring bug spray, sunscreen, and water

  • Plan it as a relaxed day, not a packed itinerary

  • Pair it with another stop (like Cayo Costa) for a full day out


From Us at KOA

We haven’t made it out there recently, but it’s high on the list—and this article does a great job capturing the feel of the place.


👉 Read the full Southern Living article here:https://www.southernliving.com/cabbage-key-fl-11918762


Your Turn 👇

Have you been to Cabbage Key?What should first-timers know? Best time to go? What did you love?


Drop your tips—I’d love to add some real KOA guest insights to this!


Comments

bottom of page