Beach Overview

When people think of Florida, they picture sandy beaches and theme parks. Pine Island is a little different—in the best way. We’re a laid-back, working island known for fishing, farming, and old Florida charm—the kind of place people come to slow down.

The good news? Some of Southwest Florida’s most beautiful beaches are just a short trip away. Here are our favorites:

Sanibel

This island paradise is back after being devastated by Hurricane Ian — and still one of the

best shelling spots in the world. I was a resident of Sanibel Island before, during, and after Ian (I’m on Matlacha now), so here’s the scoop from a local.

Visitors always ask, “What’s the best shelling beach on Sanibel?”

All of them.

Bowman's Beach and Lighthouse Beach are the most popular with visitors, but you really can’t go wrong anywhere on the island.

The shells have seasons, too—one month it’s clams, another month scallops, then olives and tulips… and if you’re really, really lucky, you might find that elusive Junonia.

The island is mostly retirees with some visiting families, so the vibe is quiet and relaxed. Restaurants and bars close at “Sanibel Midnight”… which is around 9pm.

Be prepared to pay for beach parking, and bring plenty of sunscreen and bug spray. Check out our other Sanibel posts for tips on traffic, must-see spots, and restaurant recommendations.

Getting There:

By car – approximately 75 minutes

By boat – 50–75 minutes

Tip

Check the Causeway and Periwinkle cams for traffic

Why It’s Worth the Trip From Pine Island

Quintessential beach beauty, peaceful vibe, the whole island is a nature sanctuary, fewer crowds and some of the best shelling around

Ft Myers Beach

Fort Myers Beach is back and buzzing after Hurricane Ian, and it’s the liveliest beach day

around.

If Sanibel is quiet and nature-focused, Fort Myers Beach is its livelier cousin—think soft white sand, beach bars, live music, and plenty of people-watching.

You’ll find more activity here, especially around Times Square, with restaurants, shops, and that classic “flip flops and frozen drink” kind of vibe.

Head a little further down the island if you’re looking for a quieter stretch of sand. Just a heads up—be extra careful driving. People cross the main drag everywhere.

Getting There:

By car – approximately 70 minutes

Tip

Parking fills up fast—go early if you can

Why It’s Worth the Trip From Pine Island

Lively, easy to get to, soft sandy beaches, and plenty of food, drinks, and entertainment.

North Captiva

In 1921 the Tarpon Springs Hurricane ripped Captiva Island into two parts, separated by

Redfish Pass.

North Captiva Island is only accessible by air or water, which makes it a unique blend of uncomplicated luxury. It feels like a step back into a quieter, simpler version of Florida.

The Island Club of North Captiva offers a day pass. For about $65, you get a private ferry ride, access to resort amenities and the beach, plus lunch.

Spend a few hours on the beach, then head to Mango's Cafe and Grill for lunch and a dip in the pool before kayaking or biking around the island.

Getting There:

By Private Ferry – 30 minutes (5 ferries/day)

Tip

Bring only what you can carry on your lap on the ferry, and note that coolers aren’t allowed in the resort (but are okay on the beach).

Why It’s Worth the Trip From Pine Island

Relaxed island luxury, plenty to do, and a quick, easy escape.

Cabbage Key and Cayo Costa

These are the wild islands—where nature takes the lead and the locals are mostly four-legged.

Cabbage Key is most famous for inspiring Cheeseburger in Paradise. Yes, you can still grab a cheeseburger at the restaurant. It’s a great lunch destination and often paired with a shelling trip to nearby Cayo Costa.

Cayo Costa is a Florida state park and feels much more rugged and untouched—think natural beaches, wildlife, and a true “old Florida” experience.

Getting There:

Cayo Costa by Ferry – 45 minutes

Cabbage Key by Boat - 60 minutes

Tip

Bring water, bug spray, and plenty of sunscreen—these islands are beautiful, but not designed for comfort.

Why It’s Worth the Trip From Pine Island

Old Florida at its wildest—great shelling, boat access only, and a totally unplugged beach day.

Local Info

Local author DL Havlin, set his murder mystery Turtle Point on Cayo Costa